On this page
- Why can a normal business pack miss a customer's car?
- What does a business pack give back for a customer's car?
- Do specialist motor trade policies all cover the same thing?
- Are customer vehicles, loan cars and trade plates one cover or three?
- What other differences can change a claim?
- Why does it matter whether the claim sits on property cover or liability cover?
- Does the customer's own comprehensive insurance solve the problem?
- What happens when the repair itself goes wrong?
- A claim we handled: the engine repair that became a legal demand
- If you sign a safety certificate and the car turns out unsafe, are you covered?
- What should you check on your cover for the cars in your yard?
- Common questions
Customer vehicles can need different cover while you work on them, store them or drive them. We explain what to check before you rely on a business pack.
Why can a normal business pack miss a customer's car?
A standard business pack is designed around the property the business owns and its liability to other people. A workshop also holds customers' cars, which can be worth far more than its own stock. It keeps them overnight, and its staff drive them for road testing, diagnosis or delivery.
The gap usually starts with two clauses. The liability section excludes property in your care, custody or control, and a separate exclusion removes liability involving motor vehicles. A customer's car under repair can be caught by both. Whether the wording gives any of it back, and how much, is where policies stop looking alike.
What does a business pack give back for a customer's car?
| How the policy treats customers' cars | What that means |
|---|---|
| No useful motor trade cover given back | No practical cover for customers' cars while you repair them. |
| Narrow cover given back, such as parking only | A car may be covered in a car park, but not necessarily while it is under repair or on a hoist. |
| Optional motor trade or driving risk extension | Covered only if the extension was selected and shows on the schedule, usually with its own limit and excess. |
| Cover given back automatically | Repairing cover comes back, but the limit, legal-cost treatment and driver conditions differ from wording to wording. |
| Specialist motor trade wording | Built around customer vehicles, though you still select their section. Where, when and how cover applies can differ a lot. |
Read your policy wording and schedule together, with any change written onto the policy. They show which of these you have, whatever the policy is called or costs.
Where a pack offers a motor trade extension, its limits are not large and its premium is not far off that of a full motor trade insurance policy. Which suits you turns on the cars you hold, who drives them and the work you do.
Do specialist motor trade policies all cover the same thing?
No. The motor trade wordings we place use similar labels for customers' vehicles and give them very different reach. On one, the section can apply at your premises, on the forecourt or on the road within a set distance of the workshop or collection point. That includes you or an employee driving the car for the job. On another, it applies only while you or an employee is driving the car, with no distance limit in that section. It does not apply while the car sits at your workshop or anywhere else you own, occupy or control. On a further one, it can apply at your premises and anywhere in Australia, though a car worth over $200,000 is covered only within 150 km of your workshop unless it is being collected or delivered.
On the narrower one, a car at the workshop is not automatically uninsured: the property, theft or liability sections can still be involved, depending on the schedule. What changes is the route to cover, and with it who claims and on what conditions.
Are customer vehicles, loan cars and trade plates one cover or three?
Three separate problems. On each motor trade wording we place, you select and pay for the customers' vehicles section. Some keep your own vehicles, where the loan car belongs, in a separate section; one holds both in a single motor section, switched on part by part in the schedule. None has a trade plate section.
Customers' vehicles. The car left in your care for servicing, repair, road testing, inspection or delivery. On one of the wordings we place, damage while you or your staff are driving it, including on a road test, is covered whether or not you were at fault.
The loan car. It is yours, not a customer's vehicle, and its cover works much like comprehensive cover, subject to the motor trade wording. A customer may drive it with your consent, on the wording's conditions. On one wording, a driver under 21 adds a further excess. Another covers it only within 100 km of your premises, on conditions that include checking the customer's licence and keeping a copy of it and of one other form of identification. One excludes a vehicle let for hire, so charging a daily rate can take the loan car out of cover.
Trade plates. On some of these wordings, a customer's unregistered car on a trade plate sits inside the customers' vehicles definition. Each treats an unregistered car its own way, so check rather than assume.
What other differences can change a claim?
Storm and hail. One wording may treat a customer's car like other insured property. On some others, a customer's car in your yard is not covered for hail.
Who is driving. Most of these wordings set their own excess for a young or inexperienced driver. On one, a driver under 25 in a vehicle worth over $100,000, or under 30 in one worth over $200,000, is outside the cover altogether. That matters when an apprentice takes a customer's expensive car out.
What happened to the keys. Theft using the vehicle's own key can be excluded, then partly bought back where keys were stolen from secure storage or taken by force, as the wording and schedule set out. Know where your keys sit after hours and what evidence of forced entry the wording asks for.
Why does it matter whether the claim sits on property cover or liability cover?
Because the process is different. If the car is insured as property in your care, you can generally lodge your own property claim. If the only route is liability, the customer usually has to allege you are responsible and make a demand first, sometimes through a solicitor, and that can cost you the customer.
The easier claim is usually on the property side, where the schedule shows the customers' cars as insured. Business property cover alone does not mean they are.
Does the customer's own comprehensive insurance solve the problem?
Sometimes it will be the first policy to respond, especially where nobody alleges the workshop is at fault. But not every customer has comprehensive insurance, their policy may not respond, and their insurer may later pursue you if it believes you caused the loss. A broader customers' vehicles section can give you a direct insurance route rather than waiting on the customer's policy to respond first.
What happens when the repair itself goes wrong?
Liability cover is designed for the damage or injury faulty work causes to something or someone else. It generally excludes the cost of simply redoing the defective work.
Each motor trade wording we place can add a rectification benefit that buys back part of that cost (wholesale parts and labour to redo the work), capped well short of the policy's headline limit. The trigger differs. One pays when the work itself is faulty. A second applies where a separate incident causes damage and the work has to be redone because of it. A third pays when your work damages the vehicle, only where the schedule shows it, and at your premises unless you are a mobile mechanic. So a poor repair with no other damage can get a different answer on each policy.
A claim we handled: the engine repair that became a legal demand
Case
A bolt was not correctly fastened during an engine recondition and the engine came apart. The resulting damage was covered. The technical insurance question was manageable; the customer relationship was not. The vehicle owner would not let the workshop touch the car again, arranged the repair elsewhere and then came back through a lawyer with a letter of demand. The claim was accepted and paid, but the workshop lost the customer.
If we look after your policy, a specialist claims manager on our team will run a claim like this with the insurer, and your broker will stay involved.
If you sign a safety certificate and the car turns out unsafe, are you covered?
Only if your policy carries the section that answers it. Signing a safety certificate in Queensland, or a pink or blue slip in New South Wales, is a separate risk from the repair work: somebody relied on what you wrote, put the vehicle back on the road or bought it, and now says the inspection was wrong.
On most of the motor trade policies we arrange, the cover that can answer that is professional indemnity, an optional section you select and pay for. One builds it around vehicle certificates, condition and compliance reports, pre-purchase inspections and safety reports, but treats injury or damage from a wrong certificate as a liability claim, outside professional indemnity. The other reaches a certificate claim only through a general professional duty. The third has no professional indemnity section. It gives back cover for injury or damage after a roadworthy certificate in its liability section, only if the schedule shows it.
What should you check on your cover for the cars in your yard?
Find the customers' vehicles section on the schedule. Confirm the section or extension is selected and read what it says about cars at your own premises.
Check the maximum amount insured. Use the busiest night of the year and add the vehicles together. Then check whether the limit is per vehicle, per event or across the site.
Common questions
Is a road test covered?
It can be. The motor trade wordings Consolidated Insurance Brokers places allow for your staff driving a customer's car for the job. The purpose, driver, licence conditions and distance decide whether a particular road test is covered, and the excess sets what you pay towards it.
If you have no workshop, does the risk with customers' cars go away?
No. A mobile mechanic still works on and may drive vehicles they do not own. Tools in transit, theft from the van and fitted equipment also become more important.
